Arabs & Israel.gif (346155 bytes)

www.rondavid.net  (© Ron David)

ARABSONG: Celebrations of Life

A journal of truth, humor and occasional beauty dedicated to the principle that every

human life --black, white, arab, jew, american, non-american-- is equally valuable.


from ARABS & ISRAEL FOR BEGINNERS by ©Ron & Susan David

=

At-a-Glance: How could Israel put a Jewish country on Palestinian land, against the will of the Palestinian people?

o HOME

o LINKS

 

 

I’ve built this section around three sets of facts that everybody on both sides acknowledges: 

1. the population in Palestine in 1890 before the conflict began; 

2. the U.S. government’s King-Crane Commission report in 1918 (a document that can be verified by anyone); 

3. the 1947-48 United Nations deliberations on Palestine (also easily verifiable).

CT

Fact #1—In 1890, 25,000 Jews lived in Palestine.

 

1890

l Palestine & most midEast countries petition their Ottoman Turk rulers to restore their democratic constitution.  Thousands of Jews moved to Palestine to escape pogroms [in Russia & Romania].  There was no conflict between Arabs & Jews.

1896

l Theodor Herzl, provoked by the Dreyfuss trial in France, writes The Jewish State, arguing that Jews must have a country of their own.  Herzl asks the Ottoman Sultan for Palestine: no dice! Then he tries the British—they offer him Uganda!

1905

l After Russia’s abortive revolution, thousands of Jews move to Palestine—still no conflict.

1908

l The Ottoman constitution is restored; Syria, Lebanon, & Palestine become parliamentary democracies.  Within a  few years, Palestine had 8 newspapers, 21 new periodicals, 477 schools, etc.—Lebanon & Syria thrived as well.

 

l The Zionist strategy for getting Jews to move to Palestine would surely be considered genocidal if anyone applied it to Jews: The Zionists pretended that Palestine was an empty desert.  Their ‘recruiting’slogan’ was

 “A country without a people for a people without a country.”

 

Many Jews were so shocked when they came to Palestine & found it full of people that they spoke out against the injustice.

1915

l WW 1: Ottoman Turks back the Germans; the Brits promise the Arabs independence if they help fight the Turks.

1916

l June 5: Hussein declares Arab independence, revolts against Turks; Palestine & Syria join the fight

1917

l C. Weizmann, British Zionist, gets Lord Balfour to write a ‘Declaration,’ for ‘the establishment of a national home for the Jewish people’ that doesn’t ‘prejudice the...rights of existing non-Jewish communities in Palestine’

1918

l WW 1 ends; British & French sign the Mudros Armistice, again promising the Arabs independence

 

l Somewhere along the line, the Palestinians notice that the new immigrants, the Zionists, don’t want to just live in Palestine. They want to own it.  And they want to throw the Palestinians out.  That’s when the conflict starts.

1918

l Zionists claim that Palestine belongs to them; Palestinians strongly disagree.  U.S. Prez Woodrow Wilson, thinking democratically, sent the King-Crane Commission to Palestine to talk to the people.  What they learned was clear & creepy.

 

Fact(s) #2

In 1918, 60,000 Jews lived in Palestine—an increase of 240% since 1890

n  90% of Palestine’s population was non-Jewish (after 22 years of all-out Zionist efforts, Jews made up only 10% of Palestine’s population)

n The Palestinians did NOT want a Jewish state in Palestine

n  Zionists admitted that, if they were given Palestine, they intended to throw out non-Jews

Source: US Government, King-Crane Commission report, 1918

 

 

The King-Crane Commission reported that a Jewish State in Palestine would violate the Palestinian people’s right to self-determination—they recommended that the Zionists leave Palestine alone and find another place to plant Israel.   Some very enlightening quotes from the King-Crane Commission report:  

< "the erection of a Jewish state cannot be accomplished without the gravest trespass upon the civil and religious rights of existing non-Jewish communities in Palestine."

< "The fact came out repeatedly in the Commission's conference with Jewish representatives that the Zionists looked forward to a practically complete dispossession of the present non-Jewish inhabitants of Palestine." 

< "No British officer consulted by the Commissioners believed that the Zionist program could be carried out except by force of arms.  That itself is evidence of a strong sense of injustice of the Zionist program."

< "The initial claim, often submitted by Zionist representatives, that they have a 'right' to Palestine, based on an occupation of two thousand years ago, can hardly be seriously considered."  

1919

l The Covenant of the League of Nations, Article 22: granted the ”provisional independence of the former Ottoman provinces.”

1920

l The League of Nations makes England the ‘mandatory’ [temporary teacher/ruler] of Palestine/Jordan/Iraq

1920-21

l Anti-Zionist riots convince Brits to support Arabs more, Zionists less. Brits attribute the riots to their failure to deliver on “promises of [Arab] independence and to their fear of economic & political subjugation to the Zionists."

1928

l Fights at the Wailing Wall (considered the ‘official’ beginning of the ‘conflict’) grow into small wars & cause hundreds of casualties.

1930

l Brits issue the Passfield White Paper to clarify once and for all their position on Palestine, stating: “Arabs have come to see in Jewish immigration not only a menace to their livlihood but a possible overlord of the future.” 

1931

l The Zionists nag the Brits until the Brits rescind the Passfield White Paper favoring the Arabs

1933

1934

1935

l 30,000 new Jewish immigrants enter Palestine.

l 42,000 new Jewish immigrants enter Palestine.

l 61,000 new Jewish immigrants enter Palestine.  Palestinians demand the democracy they’d been promised—AND the right, which every country has, to limit immigration. The Brits propose a meeting to settle things peaceably, the Zionists refuse

1936

l The ‘Arab revolt of 1936-39’:  The death count: 329 Jews; 3,112 Arabs.  As you will see, virtually every violent encounter between Jews & Arabs results in 10 dead Arabs for every dead Jew.  It’s amazingly consistent.

1938

l Irgun [Zionist terrorists] kill 76 Arabs by bombing public places; an Irgun member is arrested by the Brits, the Irgun kill 52 Arabs

1939

l The Brits limit Jewish immigration to Palestine to 15,000 per year, so the Irgun terrorists kill another 27 Arabs

 

l Zionist leader David BenGurion shocks other Jews by telling the truth: “...in our political argument abroad, we minimize Arab opposition to us [but] let us not ignore the truth among ourselves.”  Ben Gurion said,

“We are the aggressors and they defend themselves.”

1939

l 429,000 Jews live in Palestine, they constitute 28% of Palestine’s population. The Brits announce that unlimited Jewish immigration & giving Arab land to Jews is contrary to League of Nations’ & British promises to Arabs—& that an independent Palestinian state was probable by 1949!  The Zionists were so pissed off that they began aiming their terrorism at the British.

WW II

Even though Zionism started 40 years before the war and fanatical Zionists were more concerned with taking over Palestine than with saving Jews from concentration camps [see Alfred Lilienthal’s The Zionist Connection], no humane person should deny the wrong done—or the debt owed—to the victims of the Holocaust.  While Hitler was humiliating, robbing, and exterminating Jews, virtually every country in the world was doing nothing.  Less than nothing [see Arthur Morse’s While Six Million Died].  In my opinion, the survivors of the Holocaust should have been—and still should be—treated better than they were, but they should not have been dumped into Palestine, ignored by the Allies, and used for Zionist propaganda.  A couple facts you may not know—

n During WW II, 12,000 Palestinians enlisted in the British Army to fight the Nazis

n Palestine, a country of only 2 million people, accepted more Jewish refugees than any other country in the world  

1946-47

   

 

l After the war U.S. Prez Truman joined the Zionists in demanding that 100,000 Jews be let into Palestine. The Palestinians said NO—it was their country.  The U.S. told the Brits to force them; the Brits said NO—so the Zionists blew up the King David Hotel in Jerusalem, killing 91 Brits & several Jews.  The Brits, sick of it, gave the problem to the newly formed United Nations.

1947

l Nov: The UN, pressured by Truman (upcoming election, was groveling for the Jewish vote), met to discuss the fate of Palestine...

 

Facts #3

In 1947, 678,000 Jews live in Palestine—an increase of 653,000 since 1890

n 1,269,000 Palestinian Arabs live in Palestine

n Palestinians still have an overwhelming 2-to-1 majority

n Palestinian Arabs own over 90% of the land—Jews own only 7% of the land in Palestine

Source: United Nations General Assembly report on Palestine, Nov., 1947

 

 

 ...the U.N. delegates “provisionally partition” Palestine [they divide it to see if it’ll work]

        n They give the Zionists 55% of Palestine.  n They “give” the Palestinians (who have a 2-to-1 majority and own 90% of the land) 45% of what was 100% theirs to begin with—Palestine.  ALL the Arab & Islamic countries protest & ask to query the International Court of Justice on the right of the U.N. to partition a country against the will of its people, but they are voted down. 

l The Palestinians, taking exception to the fact that they’d been swindled out of their own country, began fighting.       

1948

l In March (after the election), the US suddenly ‘realizes’ its affront to democracy & goes on record opposing the forcible partition of Palestine.  

n March 19: The U.S. calls for the suspension of United Nations efforts to partition Palestine

n March 30: The U.S. calls for an immediate truce and further discussion by the U.N. General Assembly

 

l The Zionists ignore the US & the UN and stepped up the fighting

April

 

 

l Zionist [Irgun] terror squads led by Menachem Begin, massacre 254 women, children, & old men (the young men were working in the fields) in the Palestinian village of Deir Yassin.  Deir Yassin was one of hundreds of Zionist “land-clearing operations.”

     Zionist “land-clearing operations” were so successful that 780,000 Palestinians fled their country in terror.

May 14

l A few weeks after Deir Yassin, Israel declared itself a country. (...& the US went on record OPPOSING a Jewish state in Palestine!) 

May 20

l The UN appointed Count Bernadotte as mediator between Zionists & Arabs.  Bernadotte (who had risked his life to save 20,000 Jews from concentration camps) said that the partition of Palestine was ‘provisional’—a ‘non-binding’ test-run to see if it would work.  Since it clearly wasn’t working, both parties must return to the UN to establish where, and IF, the new Jewish country would be.  He also said that IF Zionists were ever given part of Palestine, human decency dictated that Palestinian refugees be given two options:

1. They should be allowed to return to their homes in Palestine at any time in the future

2. If they chose not to return to Palestine, they should be compensated by the Zionists for all that was taken from them. 

In summary: ALL Palestinians, at ANY time in the future, should have the choice of either Return or Compensation.

 

With Bernadotte’s war record, it would be silly to accuse him of antiSemitism.  So the next day the Zionists murdered him.    

       It was common knowledge [NY Times] that the Zionist terrorist group called The Stern Gang was responsible.  Bernadotte’s murder was ordered by Yitzhak Shamir [who would later become Prime Minister of Israel]. 

1948-49

l The war that followed has been falsified in books & movies [Exodus, etc.] as a war the Arabs started against the peace-loving Zionists and in which little David [Zionists] managed, against incredible odds, to beat Goliath.  The real story is:

    1. The Arabs agreed to a three-month truce but the Zionist ‘government’ rejected it by “a slim majority of 6 to 4.”

   2. US Army intelligence reported that the combined Arab forces totaled about 30,000 ill-equipped, poorly trained men; the Zionist army, over 90,000, outnumbered the Arabs three-to-one & had modern weapons, including new fighter planes & bombers.  They said it would be no contest.  And it wasn’t.  By the time the war was over, the Zionists had three-fourths of Palestine.

1949

l ‘Israel’ was admitted to the U.N. in May, 1949.   But there’s an interesting footnote that nobody mentions...

 

U. S. recognition of Israel was made contingent on Israel’s acceptance of the Palestinians’ right of Return or Compensation—which Israel still hasn’t granted.   So, as of this moment, America has legal grounds for NOT recognizing the country of Israel.

 

Notes

Virtually all of the above info is covered in detail in Noam Chomsky’s thoroughly documented THE FATEFUL TRIANGLE.

TAKING SIDES by Stephen Green is a great book based entirely on recently unclassified documents from U.S. Government archives.  It covers in detail Israel’s pre-state period through the 1967 war.  

For a real nightmare, see Menachem Begin’s THE REVOLT, where the psychotic prick brags about the massacre at Deir Yassin.

I have stressed the Three Sets of Facts because those facts, by themselves, prove beyond a doubt that the only thing the Palestinians are guilty of is being swindled by the Zionists. The King-Crane Report, by itself, proves the Palestinians' case: they had a huge majority, they didn’t want a Zionist state & the Zionists had slimy intentions all along. The UN report alone proves that the Zionists stole 3/4 of a country they didn’t own.  And the population figures by themselves prove the Palestinians’ case: 653,000 Jews—an increase of nearly three THOUSAND percent—moved into Palestine between 1890 and 1947—and now 4 million Palestinians live in ‘diaspora.’  Don’t be conned or misled by ‘red herrings.’ Red Herrings are picky little details & irrelevant facts tossed in to confuse the real issue and throw you off the track.  Whether a date was May or June, or an incident wasn’t mentioned or someone tries to put you on the defensive by bringing up a detail you don’t know about—nothing can change those revealing population numbers.  Or the King-Crane statistics.  Or the fact that the UN gave away a country against the will of its people and didn’t have the guts to take it back.  

And knowing that, what can change the fact that the real criminals have blamed their victims?